Disability & Policy · Article
TfL Says Floating Bus Stops Pose 'Very Low Risk,' Angering Blind Campaigners Who Say Many Now Avoid Them
The fight over cycle lanes that run between the pavement and the bus shows what injury counts can miss: the journeys disabled people no longer make.
Published · 9 min read
By Kaeleb Savon Heck
DAVAO DEL NORTE, Nov. 15, 2026 — Transport for London has published new research concluding that floating bus stops, the street layouts that make bus passengers cross a cycle lane to reach their bus, pose a "very low risk" to pedestrians, and has declined to stop building them. Blind and disability campaigners say the findings ignore what they hear every day from people who have been hit, nearly hit, or are too afraid to use the stops at all.
TfL released three reports on Friday, Nov. 13. According to the BBC, one of them admits that floating bus stops might deter older and disabled people from using public transport, but says the size of that effect is "not statistically significant." The Daily Mail reported that the analysis found the number of older and disabled passengers using floating stops fell by up to 3%, a figure TfL said did not justify action.
"Saying that blind and partially sighted people are statistically insignificant — what planet is the Mayor on?" Sarah Gayton of the National Federation of the Blind of the UK (NFBUK) told the Daily Mail. To the BBC, she called the stops "absolutely abhorrent" and "not fit for purpose for all people."
The reports land just over a week after the London Assembly voted to ask Mayor of London Sadiq Khan to pause new floating bus stops, and a month after more than 290 organisations wrote to the prime minister demanding that they be removed.
What a floating bus stop is
A floating bus stop, also called a bus stop bypass, routes a dedicated cycle lane behind the bus shelter, between the stop and the main pavement. The shelter sits on an island. To get on or off a bus, a passenger has to cross the cycle lane, usually at a zebra crossing.
Supporters say the design protects cyclists by keeping them away from buses pulling in and out. For blind and partially sighted people, the problem is that bicycles and e-bikes are quiet and fast. A person using a white cane or a guide dog may not know whether a cyclist is coming, and may not even know they have stepped off the bus into a cycle lane rather than onto a pavement.
London has at least 192 floating bus stops of different types, according to the Daily Mail's reading of the TfL reports. London Assembly figures cited by the BBC counted 164 in 2024.
What TfL found
TfL's main safety argument rests on injury data. The BBC reported that TfL counted five pedestrian casualties involving cyclists and one involving an e-scooter at floating bus stops over a three-year period, compared with 11,400 pedestrians injured by motorists in the same period. The Mail reported that TfL said incidents at the stops make up less than 1% of all pedestrian casualties involving a cyclist between 2020 and 2023. The reports said it was "rare" for a pedestrian and a cyclist to "interact" at a floating stop.
The BBC said the new analysis compares data from March to August 2018 with March to August 2023, before and after floating stops were put in. According to the Mail, TfL's estimate of the effect on older and disabled travellers was drawn from Freedom Pass data. The Freedom Pass gives Londoners of state pension age free travel after 9 a.m., and a version for disabled people has no time limits.
Other findings in the reports cut the other way. The Mail reported that TfL's own work found 60% of cyclists do not stop at the zebra crossings, and that 129 of the 192 floating stops had been "identified for improvement," 60 on TfL's own red routes and 69 on borough streets. Only 49 of them have been brought up to standard, the Mail said.
TfL told the Mail that it stood behind the reports but that the data "does not, and cannot, reflect individual passenger experiences."
Campaigners push back
Disability groups argue that injury counts miss most of the harm.
Gayton told the BBC that the real number of injuries is far higher because many incidents go unreported. "What we have is people not telling the police or reporting if they've been hurt, because they don't know who's at fault," she said. She has filmed several collisions herself, the BBC reported, five of them at the same floating stop near St Thomas' Hospital in 2024, a period the new reports do not cover.
Erik Matthies, who has sight loss and leads travel and transport policy at the Royal National Institute of Blind People (RNIB), told the BBC that RNIB research suggests 40% of blind and partially sighted people avoid floating bus stops entirely. "Low injury reports don't tell the whole story — there is no safe and accessible way for people like me to cross the cycle lane to and from a bus stop, and today's review from TfL does not address that," he said.
That figure gets at the core of the dispute. If many blind people simply stop using certain bus stops, they will not show up in injury statistics. They will show up, if at all, as journeys that never happened.
Vincent Stops, a former policy officer at London TravelWatch, told the Mail the report was "riddled with errors" and argued that the 2020–2023 window covered the pandemic, when many vulnerable people stayed home. The Mail also reported that TfL has twice withdrawn earlier papers defending the stops after leaving out information that undercut its case.
Pressure from City Hall and Westminster
On Nov. 5, the London Assembly passed a motion, 17 votes to 3, calling on the mayor to instruct TfL to pause new floating bus stops of any design on its road network, and to pause borough funding for new ones until a safe design is established.
"Every Londoner should be able to get on and off a bus without fearing for their safety," said Keith Prince, the Assembly member who proposed the motion. "Yet floating bus stops are putting pedestrians at risk, particularly blind, partially sighted, elderly and disabled Londoners."
The motion listed several incidents, including a disabled man knocked down by an e-bike rider in August 2025 as he got off a No. 1 bus on Haverstock Hill in Camden, NFBUK footage of an e-bike rider hitting a child crossing a cycle lane in south London, and footage from Lea Bridge in Waltham Forest of cyclists weaving past a wheelchair user and a blind man with a white cane. It also noted that Deputy Mayor for Transport Seb Dance has said a cyclist punched him in the face after he challenged the rider for not waiting for a pedestrian, and it cited a Telegraph investigation that found only 33 of 397 cyclists observed at three central London floating stop crossings gave way to pedestrians.
London TravelWatch, the capital's transport watchdog, has also called for a halt to new floating stops, the BBC reported.
Nationally, the BBC reported on Oct. 13 that more than 290 organisations representing blind, deaf, disabled, partially sighted and elderly people had written to the prime minister. Gary Wiggins, a visually impaired trustee of the Waltham Forest Blind Association, described being hit by a cyclist when he stepped off a bus onto what he thought was pavement. "My rollator went one way and I went another," he said.
A Department for Transport spokesperson said at the time that the government was "listening carefully" and had asked councils in November 2025 to pause work on "the most problematic type" of floating bus stop. That type, known as a shared use bus boarder, runs the cycle lane across the front of the stop, so passengers step off the bus directly into it. The pause did not cover bypasses where the cycle lane runs behind the shelter.
TfL's response
TfL said it has paused bus stop designs that require passengers to step directly into a cycle lane, but that work is continuing on three floating bus stops where cyclists pass behind the stop, according to the BBC.
"These reports provide important evidence about bus stop bypasses, the concerns that some people have raised, and the action we are taking with partners to improve safety and accessibility for all users," said Christina Calderato, TfL's director of transport strategy.
Will Norman, London's walking and cycling commissioner, said: "It's encouraging to see data confirming that the risk of bus stop bypasses to pedestrians is extremely low, but also that TfL remains committed to making this infrastructure work for everyone."
Analysis: safety is more than collisions
The fight over floating bus stops is a clear example of a wider problem in accessibility policy: measuring safety only by counting injuries. A design that frightens people out of using it can look safe on paper precisely because the people most at risk have stopped showing up.
For blind travellers, independence depends on predictability. A bus stop should be a place where you know where the kerb is, where the bus will stop, and that nothing will hit you between the pavement and the door. A crossing that depends on cyclists choosing to stop, when TfL's own figures, as reported by the Mail, suggest most do not, removes that certainty. As Gayton told the BBC last month, buses are "the big connector in London," and for people who cannot drive or cycle, losing confident access to them can mean staying home.
The cycling case is real too. Bypasses were designed to keep riders out of the path of buses, and TfL and the mayor's office argue they make streets safer overall. The question campaigners are asking is who carries the risk when that trade-off is made.
What's next
- The mayor's response: The Assembly motion is not binding. Watch whether Khan instructs TfL to pause new installations, as the Assembly asked.
- Upgrades: TfL says improvement work is continuing. With only 49 of 129 flagged stops brought up to standard, according to the Mail, progress on the rest will be a key test.
- National guidance: The Department for Transport sets design guidance for England. Campaigners want the government to go beyond last year's partial pause.
- Independent data: Disability groups are likely to keep pressing for research on avoidance and near misses, not just reported injuries.
Sources
- BBC News, "Floating bus stop report finds they pose 'low risk'": https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqy7r8vgp2d6o
- Daily Mail, "Floating bus stops prevent old, blind and disabled people using public transport, Sadiq Khan's TfL says - but refuses to scrap them": https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16290225/floating-bus-stops-old-blind-disabled-tfl.html
- London Assembly, "Pause installation of floating bus stops to keep Londoners safe": https://www.london.gov.uk/who-we-are/what-london-assembly-does/london-assembly-press-releases/pause-installation-floating-bus-stops-keep-londoners-safe
- BBC News, "Campaigners call on PM to scrap floating bus stops": https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwkg5zxmzzdvo
