Disability & Policy · Article
Disabled Philadelphians Sue Over Bike Lane Stopping Ban, Saying the ADA Requires a Way From the Car to the Door
A proposed federal class action says the citywide ban has no exception for rideshares and family cars dropping off people with mobility impairments. Cycling advocates call it a fight over parking.
Published · 7 min read
By Kaeleb Savon Heck
DAVAO DEL NORTE, Nov. 18, 2026 — Two Philadelphia residents with mobility impairments have filed a proposed class-action lawsuit in federal court arguing that the city's ban on stopping any vehicle in a bike lane violates the Americans with Disabilities Act because it has no exception for cars dropping off or picking up people with disabilities.
The lawsuit, filed last week and first reported in detail by The Philadelphia Inquirer on Nov. 16, centers on the long-contested bike lanes on Spruce and Pine Streets in Center City. But the plaintiffs say the missing exception is a citywide problem, and they want a judge to order Philadelphia to create a permit process for disabled residents whose homes sit next to a bike lane.
The case puts two groups that are often allies, cyclists and disability advocates, on opposite sides of a courtroom. It also raises a question cities around the world are struggling with as they redesign streets: how to keep bike lanes clear and safe without cutting off people who cannot walk far from a car to their front door.
What the lawsuit says
According to the Inquirer, the plaintiffs are Susan Herskovits, a Spruce Street resident in her 80s, and Carl Roeder, a Pine Street resident in his 60s. (The federal court caption, as listed by Law360, spells her surname "Herskovitz.") Both say they have had trouble getting in and out of rideshare vehicles safely since the stopping ban took effect, and that they cannot reliably reach their homes.
"A person who cannot walk a block, or cannot carry what she brings, may have no practical way from the vehicle to the door," the complaint says, as quoted by the Inquirer.
The suit asks the court to order three things, the Inquirer reported: a disability exception to the stopping ban; a process through which people with disabilities who live next to a bike lane can receive a parking or loading permit; and an accessibility evaluation of the planned safety upgrades on Pine and Spruce.
Law360, which reported the filing on Nov. 13, described the plaintiffs as a putative class of disabled Philadelphians who claim the ordinance prohibiting parking, stopping or standing in bike lanes unfairly restricts accessibility for people with mobility issues.
The complaint argues that the effect reaches beyond residents. "The same rule strands relatives, friends and guests with mobility disabilities who come to those homes," it says. "Each resident faces one rule and one missing exception, and one order can fix it."
The two sides
George Bochetto, the attorney who filed the case, told the Inquirer that the city ignored attempts to resolve the issue out of court. "The Americans with Disabilities Act requires municipalities to make reasonable accommodations for the disabled," he said. "We are not going to go away."
A spokesperson for the city's law department declined to comment, according to the Inquirer.
Philly Bike Action, a cycling safety group, pushed back hard. In a statement to the Inquirer, it said that "disability advocates and AARP have long touted" the safety benefits of bike lanes, and that additional loading zones blocked by an earlier lawsuit were meant to "provide adequate curbside access." The group called the new case "nothing more than an attempt by a privileged group of neighbors to keep their parking spots."
The plaintiffs say the city was warned. The lawsuit says accessibility concerns were raised in public hearings on the bike lane plan and in earlier litigation. It also says Disability Rights Pennsylvania, a disability rights watchdog, asked the city last December to "retract and remove" the stopping ban and revise the bike lane plan so that people with disabilities can "freely enter and exit their premises, to have access to their transportation, and to move about in the community," the Inquirer reported.
How the street got here
The fight over Spruce and Pine has been running since the bike lanes were painted in 2009, the Inquirer and the Philadelphia Focal both noted.
The current stopping ban and the plan to upgrade the lanes followed a death. In 2024, Barbara Friedes, a 30-year-old physician at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, was killed when a drunk driver veered into the Spruce Street bike lane, the Inquirer reported. The city then banned stopping in bike lanes citywide and unveiled a plan to protect the Spruce and Pine lanes with concrete barriers, along with loading zones on the opposite side of the street for residents to use.
That plan was itself blocked in court. A residents' group, Friends of Pine and Spruce, sued in 2025, calling the loading zone plan regulatory overreach. That summer, Common Pleas Court Judge Sierra Thomas-Street ruled the city had no legal authority to remove parking spaces for the loading zones and barred the city from changing the lanes. After City Council passed legislation giving the Streets Department power over parking changes, the city asked a different judge, Damaris L. Garcia, to lift the injunction in June, but she declined. The city's appeal is pending in Commonwealth Court, according to the Inquirer.
The result is a stalemate. The safety upgrades have been frozen for more than a year, but the citywide ban on stopping in bike lanes remains, with no carve-out for disabled passengers. The new federal suit is, in the Inquirer's words, a second legal front.
What the ADA requires
Title II of the ADA covers state and local governments. Under the Justice Department's regulations, public entities must make reasonable modifications to their policies, practices and procedures when needed to avoid discrimination against people with disabilities, unless the change would fundamentally alter the program or service. That is the legal hook for the plaintiffs' demand: they are not asking the city to remove the bike lanes, but to modify the rule so that it bends for people who cannot safely get from a car to a door any other way.
The city has not yet filed a response, and no court has ruled on whether the stopping ban without an exception violates the law.
Analysis: a curb is a shared space
For many disabled people, the last 30 feet of a trip is the hardest part. A wheelchair user needs a level spot to deploy a ramp. A person with a mobility impairment may not be able to walk a block from a legal stopping spot. A blind traveler depends on being dropped where the driver says, close to a known entrance, without having to cross an unfamiliar lane of fast bike traffic to find the curb.
At the same time, bike lane advocates have a real safety argument, and Friedes' death is the reason this rule exists. Cars stopped in bike lanes push cyclists into traffic, and a blanket ban is easier to enforce than a patchwork of exceptions. Blind and low-vision pedestrians also have their own stake in well-designed bike infrastructure, as this Chronicle reported earlier this month in the dispute over London's floating bus stops.
The ironic part of the Philadelphia fight is that the city's own plan seemed to anticipate the problem. Loading zones across from the bike lane were meant to give residents curb access, but those zones were blocked by neighbors who wanted to keep parking. The disabled plaintiffs are now asking for a version of curb access through a different door.
How a federal judge handles that tension could matter well beyond Center City. Cities that are expanding protected bike networks will be watching whether a blanket stopping ban can stand under the ADA, or whether it needs a disability permit system built in from the start.
What's next
The case will proceed in federal court in Philadelphia, where the city is expected to respond to the complaint and the court will eventually decide whether to certify the case as a class action. Separately, the city's Commonwealth Court appeal over the frozen Spruce and Pine upgrades remains pending. Until one of those cases moves, the stopping ban stays in place, the planned barriers and loading zones remain on hold, and residents who cannot walk far are left to negotiate the curb on their own.
Sources
- Philly's ban on stopping in bike lanes violates federal disability protections, lawsuit says — The Philadelphia Inquirer
- Philly Hit With Class Claims Over Bike Lane Stopping Ban — Law360
- Herskovitz et al v. City of Philadelphia, case page — Law360
- Federal Lawsuit Challenges Philadelphia's Bike Lane Stopping Ban as Violating Disability Rights — The Philadelphia Focal
- ADA Title II regulations, 28 CFR Part 35 — ADA.gov
